|
Manei Catalyst
BattleTech Developer
Posts: 14710
|
Catalyst has posted a press release and requested it be broadcast to all corners. Keep the discussion relevant, non-inflammatory and generally on a good even keel or your post will be removed. Out right flamage of any kind will be dealt with accordingly. http://catalystgamelabs.com/2010/03/17/catalyst-game-labs-press-release/
|
|
|
Recruit
Posts: 20
|
Where's my mini's?  mgctch? Ahhhh come on...don't tell me you took your ball and went home? The fun's just startin....  Sigh...he seems to have left. WAIT! He's baccckk...no, he's gone.
|
|
|
Private
Posts: 30
|
From a strictly business point-of-view, this has got to be one of the best damage control press releases I've ever read. Truly excellent. Banks and insurance companies should take notes. 
|
|
|
Master Sergeant
Posts: 331
The sword should never lead the heart.
|
I thought it was well done and to be honest it was posted faster than I would've expected... which to me is a good sign.
The truth is, even if the worse does happen we know Battletech (And other related franchises) will survive, how can I be so sure... because quite frankly it's happened before and we're still here.
|
|
|
Recruit
Posts: 20
|
I agree the post was well done. The timeline leading up to it....
|
|
|
Captain
Posts: 2511
|
It makes me very sad to see Catalyst in this situation. Complaints or not i think we all love the work you guys do for our beloved game. I hope things work out ok for Catalyst and Battletech.
|
|
|
Master Sergeant
Posts: 289
Lyran L.O.K.I Loyalist
|
Meh, a little saddened by the news. But I've been a fan of Catalyst for a few years now, I'll stick with 'em.
|
|
|
Lieutenant Colonel
Posts: 9133
Zero G is good for you
|
So things aren't perfect, but they aren't terrible either. Guess we'll just keep on keeping on. So long as CGL keeps provideing us with excelent games material everything will be just fine.
|
|
|
Lieutenant Colonel
Posts: 8229
WORK is for those who don't know how to PLUNDER
|
It makes me very sad to see Catalyst in this situation. Complaints or not i think we all love the work you guys do for our beloved game. I hope things work out ok for Catalyst and Battletech.
ditto
|
|
|
Master Sergeant
Posts: 272
Eater of worlds!
|
Sometimes the most important things are what is not said. I agree that it is good that Catalyst got something up for the record fairly quickly. I think it was 6 hours from when I first read about it to now. I may disagree with the wholesale deletion of posts, but damage control is a risky and difficult procedure. Running a business, and being involved in small businesses, I've seen this happen before. This will not cause me to stop buying Catalyst products. Good luck to all of you and us!
|
|
|
Warrant Officer
Posts: 490
The Marian Hegemony's Official Jack-booted Thug
|
Gosh. That press release leaves me speechless.
Well, almost.
Cent13
|
|
|
Captain
Posts: 1671
Dante's 7th Armored Cav.
|
Wow...I'm glad something was able to come out now instead of letting people have a whole night to stew and work over speculations. Thanks CGL, for that. Thanks CGL for this... "Upon further investigation, in which the owner has willingly participated, the owner in question now owes the company a significant balance and is working to help rectify the situation." I've seen other companies give up. I've seen other business owners cut and run, letting the court systems decide their fate. I've worked for businesses that run into this as they grow. I've seen marriages ended due to these kinds of financial issues, just on a smaller scale. From the statement, and appearances, CGL and all involved are trying to resolve this as best as they all can try to, but they are -trying-. It makes me very sad to see Catalyst in this situation. Complaints or not i think we all love the work you guys do for our beloved game. I hope things work out ok for Catalyst and Battletech.
QFT. I've enjoyed BattleTech more in the CGL era than any other. I'm loving their casual games. I'm excited as heck about Leviathans. ...being involved in small businesses, I've seen this happen before. This will not cause me to stop buying Catalyst products. Good luck to all of you and us!
Same here...my support stands, and I can only wish and hope for a smooth resolution and recovery for all.
|
|
|
Master Sergeant
Posts: 272
Eater of worlds!
|
Sometimes when running a small business, it is all you can do to get done the work for today, and hope for a couple oh hours tomorrow to do all the other things a business is supposed to do. Yes, I should keep the books updated, or yes I need to file this or process that, but there are just not enough hours in a day--and that's when somebody ISN'T out trying to defraud you and covering his tracks.
|
|
|
Manei Catalyst
BattleTech Developer
Posts: 14710
|
I have removed a post from this thread.
Please stick to facts and not bring conjecture into this. There are a lot of rumors running around and a lot of false information going with it. You can express concern, you can express support, but stick to facts.
|
|
|
Manei Catalyst
BattleTech Developer
Posts: 14710
|
That is baloney Welshman and you know it. I stated that I was expressing my opinion based on 30 years of experience as an attorney working in the area of Civil Fraud and Racketeering along with having been a state bank fraud examiner. Some of my cases have been argued in the Supreme Courts of three states as well as in the United States Supreme Court. Moreover the discussion of options are fully reasonable. Can you provide me with any option that I did not consider, other than folding the company?
I'll answer this once and only once. Future posts will be removed. Your post was removed because it mentions specific amounts and specific parties. None of that information is known by anyone but Catalyst at this time (That includes myself and the volunteer staff on the boards). You can speculate all you want, but stick to the facts you can prove and remember that this forum has tight rules on conduct, trolling and anything that borders on defamation. I'm not a lawyer, I don't have to be a lawyer, this site doesn't have to be a lawyer. We have a posted set of rules and that includes Rule 12. Stick to the facts that are public and we'll all be fine.
|
|
|
Monsters in the Sky!
Moderator
Posts: 20560
Luft Konteradmiral, K.u.K. Luftflotte
|
That is baloney Welshman and you know it. I stated that I was expressing my opinion based on 30 years of experience as an attorney working in the area of Civil Fraud and Racketeering along with having been a state bank fraud examiner. Some of my cases have been argued in the Supreme Courts of three states as well as in the United States Supreme Court. Moreover the discussion of options are fully reasonable. Can you provide me with any option that I did not consider, other than folding the company?
With your experience, I'm suprised that you're prepared to assert unsubstantiated rumours as if they were facts. Please note, all - there is no factual basis for any dollar value claims, and unless you've got notarised ledgers we'll react accordingly. As is mentioned earlier: Keep the discussion relevant, non-inflammatory and generally on a good even keel or your post will be removed. Out right flamage of any kind will be dealt with accordingly. Making unsupported allegations and assertions is not non-inflammatory. Worktroll, Moderator
|
|
|
Recruit
Posts: 20
|
Sometimes when running a small business, it is all you can do to get done the work for today, and hope for a couple oh hours tomorrow to do all the other things a business is supposed to do. Yes, I should keep the books updated, or yes I need to file this or process that, but there are just not enough hours in a day--and that's when somebody ISN'T out trying to defraud you and covering his tracks.
I'll try again... Dear GreatSarcasmo, I respectfully disagree with you assertations since they have no basis in fact to indicate that this issue is the result of minor things not getting done on the odd day. Thank-you...I"m here all week. 
|
|
|
Master Sergeant
Posts: 202
|
Tell you what Welshman, if you want to continue deleting my posts without first discussing the content of the article so that I can self modify what you believe to be unsubstantiated rumors, I will stop posting here and post on Boardgame Geek and Consim World. Would that be better for you?
As for facts that can be proved, the facts on which I am debating was relayed by a prominent writer for Shadowrun in their forum which has not had the practice of deletion in which you seem to be engaging. Furthermore, there is a posting by the former bookkeeper and operations manager of CGL. As a statement from persons with knowledge they are not hearsay nor rumors.
As for defamation, truth is a defense. Second, both Mr. Coleman and Bills are persons in the public eye and thus subject to lesser scrutiny than a private person. Third, as a public company which solicits money from me, information about their status communicated and discussed with fellows of similar interests is a privileged communication - allowing for speculation and discussion. Fourth, oh why go on.
|
|
|
Captain
Posts: 2511
|
Guys we don't know all the facts. I admit that this news is hard to hear. It sounds like from Catalyst official response that some of the freelancers haven't got paid. I had hoped after FASA close that those days would never happen again. It has. My hearts go out to them and I hope they get there money soone. Catalyst is letting us know as much as they can what is going on.
The good news is Catalyst isn't the first game company to have something like this happen. I know Palladium had something simular happen. They are still around. So I have great hope things will be alright.
As someone who was around when FASA closed there doors take my advice. Do not flip out and over react. Because if you do I will tell you first hand the odds are you will regret it.
|
|
|
Lieutenant Colonel
Posts: 8395
Wielder of the Holy Heavy Bolter of Bethlehem
|
It's great to see Catalyst turnover is on the up at least. Bookeeping goofs happen afterall... fairly often in small businesses, where one party often ends up wearing three or more hats, in my experience.
I'll take the release at face value. It's good to know everyone is on the ball but sad to hear someone felt the need to walk away because of this. Best of luck to them and everyone at CGL.
|
|
|
Master Sergeant
Posts: 331
The sword should never lead the heart.
|
I know Palladium had something simular happen. They are still around. So I have great hope things will be alright.
Referenced this earlier and I couldn't agree more. Thank you.
|
|
|
Warrant Officer
Posts: 676
|
|
|
|
Recruit
Posts: 20
|
Hey, I love CBT just the same as all of you...that doesn't change the fact that I have serious ethical concerns with what happened. The fact that another company survived doesn't mean that everything's blissfully serene....
|
|
|
Private
Posts: 28
|
Third, as a public company which solicits money from me
Huh? Since when is Catalyst a public company? What exchange are they traded on?
|
|
|
Manei Catalyst
BattleTech Developer
Posts: 14710
|
Where are these rules of posting located?
On the button bar at the top of the screen, right next to the one that says "Forums". Yes you can take your discussion a lot of places. But as long as you are here, you need to follow the rules of this forum. We run a tight ship, so that this forum can support such a diverse community. Thank you, Welshman
|
|
|
Warrant Officer
Posts: 676
|
I'll answer this once and only once. Future posts will be removed.
Your post was removed because it mentions specific amounts and specific parties. None of that information is known by anyone but Catalyst at this time (That includes myself and the volunteer staff on the boards).
You can speculate all you want, but stick to the facts you can prove and remember that this forum has tight rules on conduct, trolling and anything that borders on defamation.
I'm not a lawyer, I don't have to be a lawyer, this site doesn't have to be a lawyer. We have a posted set of rules and that includes Rule 12.
Stick to the facts that are public and we'll all be fine.
Welshman, while the rules do include Rule 12, I think the pertinent one is actually Rule 13.
|
|
|
Warrant Officer
Posts: 676
|
Sticking to the facts I read rule 12 and it stated that copyright products cannot be passed around...fail to see how this applies.
Because the relevant rule is 13.
|
|
|
Lieutenant Colonel
Posts: 8684
|
Countdown to threadlock in four...three...
(let's see if I get this in before the thread's got to be locked down...)
First off, the press release is refreshingly honest, as well as having a great deal of basic decency in not naming names. Second, it's being handled internally, and IIRC, Catalyst is an LLC (Limited Liabilty Company), so there's no stockholders to panic with news of this sort (and by that panic, no requirement that further legal action is required between the company, and the partner/owner in question!)
So, with nobody getting sued, and the company not drowning in red ink, and a nice, already-negotiated and declared-out-front deal in place, what's the problem? CGL's managed to stay above water in what has turned out to be one of the shittiest economies of the last forty years, in spite of existing in a shrinking general market and against far better established competitors with deeper reserves and less ethical business practices.
Okay, so someone screwed up, and now owes the company money. (Shrug) unless he jumps on the deal and takes a runner, this is just...well, it's news that the guys still have their business-end act together, that's all.
Unless someone who was SUPPOSED to get paid didn't, there isn't the kind of fatal problem FASA had.
|
|
|
Captain
Posts: 2511
|
Hey, I love CBT just the same as all of you...that doesn't change the fact that I have serious ethical concerns with what happened. The fact that another company survived doesn't mean that everything's blissfully serene....
That is true. But we don't have all the facts in this situation to know if we should panic. We know that there has been a finacial problem large enough were they felt they had to make an anouncment. But that is all we know. Frankly there could be very good legal reasons they are not saying more. I am willing to take what Randall says at face value. He is put in a lot of sweat and put up with a lot of crap from players including myself over the years. So as far as I am concerned I owe him to take what he says at face value. But I can tell from experience that losing your cool in all this will led to two things. One you lossing a little bit of the love you have for the game. Two more importantly if you get mad you tend to say things you will regret. So I am just saying try to be calm and rash and go on what little facts we have.
|
|
|
Recruit
Posts: 20
|
Countdown to threadlock in four...three...
(let's see if I get this in before the thread's got to be locked down...)
That would be a mistake of Titanic proportions. But hey, it's not my company, just my $$$.
|
|
|
Master Sergeant
Posts: 272
Eater of worlds!
|
I'll try again... Dear GreatSarcasmo, I respectfully disagree with you assertations since they have no basis in fact to indicate that this issue is the result of minor things not getting done on the odd day. Thank-you...I"m here all week.  I wasn't saying that was the case. In fact I was responding to deleted post that was inquiring as to how something like this could happen, and how nobody noticed. My response was just one way that something like that could have happened. I make no pretense to knowing anything not spelled out on the press release, and apologize if you thought I did.
|
|
|
Captain
Posts: 2036
Avatar by the Wombat -- User bar by xtrahmxwohld
|
Well, it's clear that something unplesent has happened. To what level, I have no idea. But I do know that people on this board are going to be chiming in with what they've heard, and sooner or later, what actually happened will be burried under a mound of half-truths, exagarations and out and out falsehoods. The owners of CGL are aware of the problem: is up to them to decide what to do. They will make their decision based on facts presented to them, fact that we probably never know (After all, do we know why Microsoft makes certain decisions?).
I have been reading through threads on other forums, and there is wild speculations about the people and amonts involved. There is also speculations about who will pick up the licences for these products if/when CGL goes under. Speculations that have nothing solid behind them! I don't know the people making the claims about amounts/people involved -- they may be true, they may not. There may any number of scenarios that played out here, but because most of us are not involved deeply with CGL, we don't know any/all the facts -- the owners of CGL do know/will know all the facts. If it's a court case, it is up to the owners to decide, not us.
I know people are pissed -- Hell, I am pissed. But who do we get pissed at? Why waste our anger on someone who may not deserve it? All I am asking is that we let the CGL owners decide what to do. It's their reputation on the line.
So, please, let's take a step back and sees what happenes, okay?
Craig
|
|